17 Comments
User's avatar
Brian Reindel's avatar

We need to know where we stand before we stand there, and then imagine the worst of what will happen before we even take the first step toward that place. If we don't, our courage will immediately wane.

This came at a great time. I'm in the process of writing an essay about how authors can craft meaningful science fiction and fantasy. Orwell is one of the primary examples I use, and now you've given me more to consider. Thanks, Charles!

Charles Schifano's avatar

Thank you for the comment, Brian.

Sherman Alexie's avatar

Great stuff, Charles. This essay is urgent and we need urgency now in the book world.

Sherman Alexie's avatar

“What do I know? What’s true? What’s false? What don’t I know? Writers should probably have those answers before they hear the knocks.”

Trilety Wade's avatar

Oooo again, so lush! And again, you write like an intellectual call to arms, but with a powerful subtlety that really gets me going! This is so much. I hope to be as true to my word as Orwell. While I read a great book about his journalism days called Finding George Orwell in Burma, I did not know that he died without money or friends. Really enjoy your writing.

Charles Schifano's avatar

Thank you very much for the comment and kind words, Trilety.

Michael Edward's avatar

This is great. I throughly enjoyed the way you illuminated Orwell’s conviction and used it as a way to highlight the importance of being precise and true with our words.

This was a wonderfully well written read.

Thank you

Charles Schifano's avatar

Thank you very much for the kind words, Michael.

Michael Mohr's avatar

“A small, expedient solution is always justified in the moment as the necessary shortcut, the needed conclusion, the agreeable fiction; yet all of these lapses will, eventually, inevitably, compound into something much greater.”

Yes. And this describes our current polarized political moment on both sides. And both sides tout “Orwellian” as describing the “other side.” Very ironic and typical of contemporary America.

I wrote about Orwell here: https://michaelmohr.substack.com/p/george-orwell-a-life

Michael Mohr

‘Sincere American Writing’

https://michaelmohr.substack.com/

Charles Schifano's avatar

Thank you for the comment, Michael.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 16, 2023
Comment deleted
Charles Schifano's avatar

Although he later criticized the novel, I've always appreciated Burmese Days. Flawed, a little disjointed, but there's still a lot that's worthwhile. And, of course, there's value in almost all the critical essays. Thank you for the comment, John.

Michael Mohr's avatar

His essays are spectacular. Politics and the English Language is fantastic.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 16, 2023
Comment deleted
Charles Schifano's avatar

I certainly agree—and there are subjects for everyone. Personal, literary, travel, political, etc. Thank you for the comment.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 16, 2023
Comment deleted
Charles Schifano's avatar

Thank you for the kind words—I appreciate it.